For the last 15 years, Satinder Paul Singh Dhillon has been in and out of court battling against accounting giant KPMG. He has been alleging that there was serious wrong doing by KPMG, when they were the trustee on a file, in which he is the largest creditor and owed millions of dollars. Mr. Dhillon, whose parents were born in India and left the country with less than $10 in their pocket, to pursue what Dhillon calls the Canadian Dream, is alleged to have written a blog. For this he was charged with contempt of court. He is facing a potential jail sentence, if convicted.
In a shocking ruling, Judge Heather Holmes, of the Supreme Court of British Columbia, has ruled that Dhillon cannot use the truth in his defence. Further to this the judge has ruled he cannot view the file that KPMG has, despite now being charged with the crime of posting a blog. Dhillon has been requesting this file from KPMG for 15 years now to no avail. Even though they are mandated by law to provide him with the file.
Dhillon has also been denied the right to have the people that instigated the charges questioned on the witness stand, under oath. Further to this he was also denied the right to have the trial televised. Dhillon had asked that it be televised because he felt it was in the public’s interest to see what was going on.
Dhillon alleges that the cover-up of one of the largest income tax frauds ever perpetrated in Canadian history, is at the heart of the persecution he has been facing for over a decade and a half now. “It’s ironic and sad that taxpayers money is being used to cover-up a tax fraud” Dhillon stated, when contacted in New York for comment.
On January 19th, 2015, Dhillon will be forced to put on a defence without the testimony of key witnesses being allowed, or the use of the truth.
When asked for further comment, Dhillon stated, “I think it is pretty obvious now for the world to see what is really going on here in Canada. When a judge says a person cannot even use the truth in their defence, what can you really say in response to that? It is beyond words, nothing they do shocks me now. The whole situation is out in the open now, and the citizens of Canada can decide, what they think is the reason why I am not allowed to use the truth in my defence”.
During the previous round of this trial. Which has been on again, off again, over the past 8 months, protesters took to the streets in support of Dhillon, to show their discontent at the judge’s ruling that he could not even use the truth in his defence, or question any of the key witnesses, which included people whose names appear in the blog.
Dhillon has hired Mr. Jamshed Mistry, a well-known lawyer from Mumbai, and member of the Canadian Bar Association and Mr. Mark Stephens (Julian Assange’s former attorney from the U.K.), to assist him in dealing with the ancient law that is being applied in his case, which is the last exception left under Common Law in Canada.
Under this law Dhillon is not allowed to have a jury of his peers, despite potentially facing time in jail. Also it is the judge herself, Heather Holmes, that decides if the case should proceed or not, and not the prosecutor’s office, as is normally the case in most countries, including India and Canada.
The law that is being used against Dhillon is so old, that technically in Canada, the death penalty still applies. This is despite the fact that Canada abolished the death penalty in 1976, which is the year before Dhillon was born.
Dhillon has conducted most of the trial himself in Canada, due to the fact he was not allowed by the judge to retain a lawyer to represent him. Justice Healther Holmes stated that she thought he was qualified enough to conduct his own defence, even though Dhillon has no legal training. At one point in the trial the judge even went as far as stating that Dhillon "has a well developed sense of strategy". Dhillon paid one of his Canadian lawyers tens of thousands of dollars and was officially on the record for him, who at the last minute wilted under pressure from KPMG and others.
Dhillon said, “currently there is an affidavit under seal in court, showing exactly what happened with my previous lawyers”. He further went on to state that he has the right to unseal the affidavit anytime he chooses to, and then it would become public record. It was only because he did not want to injure his previous lawyer, if the affidavit became public, that Dhillon has not unsealed it thus far. Dhillon said the conduct that is alleged in the affidavit left “me high and dry at the eleventh hour”. Just prior to the trial commencing in June of 2014, Dhillon was hospitalized, and almost died, shortly after his lawyer went off the record. Despite still being in the hospital and nearly dying, on the eve of the trial, Judge Heather Holmes had the trial proceed.
“KPMG is the fourth largest accounting firm on the planet, and they have a lot of power in the world and most people don’t want to battle against large corporations like that. Especially one that was able to have me arrested and charged for the allegation of posting a blog. That is a serious amount of power” said Dhilon.
“KPMG stated, and this is on the record, that they wanted to “silence” me, and that I have a “target on my back”, these are their words not mine” added Dhillon.
Dhillon stated in his interrogation that $800 million dollars was involved, and that KPMG was doing anything they could to avoid having to answer for what happened.
“In the end the Canadian lawyer I had just buckled under the pressure and that is why I have other lawyers from outside of Canada on this case. Even though it hurt a lot to be sold out like that at the last minute, I can understand why, as my lawyer had a young family to think about, and the implication to his career if he battled KPMG, and the many others involved in this matter. He should have just told me from the beginning that he couldn’t take on a giant like KPMG before taking my money under false pretenses, but as they say in french, 'c’est la vie'. You live you learn, and I’ve learned the hard way what this country is all about” said Dhillon.
Dhillon who was in Mumbai, in October of 2014, and was invited to speak at the Aam Aadmi party’s headquarters, on Gandhi’s birthday, said that he also felt much safer in the country of his parents birth than in Canada.
While being interrogated Dhillon was told by one of the police officer’s not to try and be like Malcolm X or Gandhi.
When asked about these comments that were made by the police officer, Dhillon stated "Malcolm X was fighting for a much more important cause that mattered a heck of a lot more than what I am dealing with”.
“At the end of all of this, it’s not like a country is going to gain freedom, or civil rights are going to be given to a group of marginalized citizens. Those things mattered a lot more than what we are fighting against. It’s not right for the police officer to have put me in the same sentence as those people”.
"This situation is just a case of large corporations doing what has become all too common these days. What has made it worse is that the government and the courts have been assisting in the persecution. There is one common theme though and that is injustice. That is the common thread that binds this cause to the many others around the world, where injustice is at the heart of what is going on”, stated an observer.
More protests are being planned by supporters of Dhillon, for January 19th, 2015, as evidenced by this Facebook page - https://www.facebook.com/ events/1525800254337689/? source=1
A ‘Stand in Solidarity with Satinder’ movement has begun in multiple cities around the world.
Dhillon, who was in New York, along with Kanye West, Katie Couric, Spike Lee, Kim Kardashian, Josue Sejour, the mayor of Jersey City, Steven Fulop, D.J. Q-Tip, and others, attending a private birthday party, and 10 year anniversary of the release of his first album, for grammy award winning artist John Legend, when we contacted him, said “ Currently I feel safer in America and India, than I do in the country in which I was born. But the Canadian passport has allowed me to travel, and experience some amazing things in this lifetime, and for that I am thankful to the country of my birth, one in which my parents laid down roots after suffering through much hardship.
I do not plan on leaving on a permanent basis anytime soon, as their sacrifice is what allowed me to be able to have this passport, which allows me unfettered access to the entire world. I have much respect for the founding principles of my country and the sacrifices my parents made, so I could be the citizen of a free country like Canada, but the current situation has just made my life a bit difficult, to say the least, for the time being", added Dhilon.
To read more click here: